IELTS HUBIELTS Discussion Essay on Family & Education & Society
Full IELTS Writing Task 2
You should spend about 40 minutes on this task.
Some people believe that discipline in children should be instilled by parents, while others think that teachers should take this responsibility.
Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Write at least 250 words.
Introduction
Introduce the two contrasting views on who is responsible for instilling discipline in children (parents vs. teachers). State the author's personal opinion (parents should primarily have this role).
Body Paragraph 1 View 1
Present the arguments for why teachers should teach discipline. Points include: teachers are trained professionals with knowledge in methods and psychology; the structured school environment is ideal for learning rules and consequences.
Body Paragraph 2 View 2
Present the arguments for why parents should teach discipline (and the author's preferred view). Points include: parents have a unique emotional connection allowing for tailored discipline; parents can provide consistent reinforcement throughout daily life, making discipline a habit.
Body Paragraph 3 Opinion (Optional If Integrated)
Not applicable as opinion is integrated into Body Paragraph 2.
Conclusion
Summarize the main points discussed for both sides (teacher training/school structure vs. parent emotional connection/continuous reinforcement). Restate the author's opinion that parents are better suited for this role.
Band 9 Sample Answer:
There are two main views on who should be responsible for teaching discipline to children: parents or teachers. I personally believe that this role should mainly fall on parents.
Those who think teachers should teach discipline have their reasons. First, they say that teachers are trained and knowledgeable in teaching methods and child psychology, which makes them capable of effectively managing children's behavior. Second, they believe that the structured and rule-based school environment is perfect for teaching discipline. They argue that this consistent environment helps children understand the importance of discipline and its consequences.
However, despite these strong points, I lean more towards the idea that parents should be the main ones to teach discipline. One reason is the special emotional connection between parents and children. I think this connection allows parents to adjust their discipline methods to fit their child's unique personality and needs, which a teacher, who has to deal with many children, might not be able to do. Also, parents have more time to consistently reinforce discipline throughout a child's daily life, not just during school hours. I believe this constant reinforcement is key to making discipline a habit, not just a rule enforced at school.
In summary, while there are good arguments for teachers teaching discipline, like their professional training and the structured school environment, I think the emotional connection and continuous reinforcement that parents provide make them the better choice for this role.
Band 7 Sample Answer:
There exists a dichotomy of beliefs regarding the instillation of discipline in children; some advocate for parental responsibility, while others champion the role of teachers. Personally, I align myself with the former viewpoint, asserting that parents should primarily shoulder this duty.
Those who believe that teachers should be the ones to instill discipline in children have their reasons. Firstly, they argue that teachers are trained professionals, well-versed in pedagogical techniques and child psychology. This expertise, they contend, equips teachers with the skills to effectively manage and guide children's behavior. Secondly, they posit that the school environment, with its structured routine and clear rules, is an ideal setting for discipline to be instilled. This setting, they argue, provides a consistent framework within which children can learn the importance of discipline and its consequences.
However, despite these valid arguments, I am more inclined towards the belief that parents should be the primary instillers of discipline. One reason for this is the unique emotional bond between parents and children. This bond, I believe, allows parents to tailor their disciplinary methods to their child's individual temperament and needs, something a teacher, dealing with numerous children, may not be able to do. Furthermore, parents have the advantage of time, being able to reinforce discipline consistently throughout a child's daily life, not just during school hours. This constant reinforcement, I argue, is crucial in ingraining discipline as a habit rather than a school-imposed rule.
In conclusion, while there are valid arguments for teachers instilling discipline, such as their professional training and the structured school environment, I believe the emotional bond and continuous reinforcement offered by parents make them the stronger candidates for this responsibility.