Paraphrase topic (two views on creating art). State author's opinion (requires special talent).
There exists a dichotomy of views regarding the creation of quality art: some believe it to be a universal ability, while others argue it necessitates a unique talent. I align myself with the latter perspective, asserting that artistry is an innate skill.
Topic sentence for view 1 (anyone can create art). Points: Widespread digital tools and sharing (blurring lines, self-taught artists). Art is subjective (amateur vs. masterpiece).
Those advocating for the universality of artistic creation often cite the democratization of art tools as a key factor. With the advent of digital technology, art has become accessible to a wider audience, allowing anyone with a computer or smartphone to create and share their work. This accessibility, they argue, has blurred the line between professional and amateur artists, as seen in the rise of successful self-taught digital artists. Moreover, they point to the subjective nature of art appreciation. What one person deems a masterpiece, another might dismiss as amateurish, suggesting that quality art is not necessarily tied to professional training or innate talent.
Topic sentence for view 2 (requires unique talent) and justification for author's opinion. Points: Consistent outstanding work by trained artists (Picasso, Van Gogh) shows talent beyond skill. Expressing complex emotions requires insight (Kahlo, Banksy).
However, I am inclined to side with those who believe that quality art requires a special talent. The first argument for this view is the consistent excellence seen in the works of trained artists. For instance, the masterpieces of renowned artists like Picasso or Van Gogh, both of whom had formal art training, have a depth and complexity that is rarely matched by amateur artists. This, proponents argue, is evidence of a unique talent that goes beyond mere technical skill. Furthermore, they argue that art is not just about creating visually appealing pieces, but also about communicating complex emotions and ideas. This requires a level of emotional intelligence and perceptiveness that is not common to all individuals, and can be seen in the profound impact of works by artists such as Frida Kahlo or Banksy.
Summarize main points (availability of tools vs. quality of trained artists). Restate opinion (special talent is necessary).
In conclusion, while the democratization of art tools and the subjective nature of art appreciation provide some support for the notion that anyone can create quality art, the consistent excellence and emotional depth seen in the works of trained artists suggest that special talent is indeed a prerequisite.
